However the scene with Palpatine and Anakin where Palpatine was talking about how the Dark Side could preserve life was a very good scene.

I agree with much of what you say. However, and I don't remember the exact scene in Amadeus, but how do you get from - - "Displace one note and there would be diminishment, displace one phrase and the structure would fall," - - to "An artist blessed with the power of greatness could have accomplished so much more,"?

Wasn't he saying that Amadeus' compositions were indeed singular and genius in that without one aspect or note they would be somehow flawed because the genius of Mozart could be trusted down to the last note/stanza?

Surely you're right that Lucas has no such stature. His prose and handling of actors is incredibly clunky - - though Palpatine and ObiWan were very good.

But how do we get to the responsibility of his greatness?

The rest is just hard work.

Understanding and recognizing quality is the hard part. There's no coherent theory of art at the moment, so much of the ability to recognize quality comes mostly from intuition and experience. Some people will be better at it than others. Few will be perfect.

That's why it's rare to find an artist who doesn't need an editor. Mozart was one of them. Lucas isn't.

I think Lucas understands what quality is on a large scale, but I don't think he quite gets it at the detailed level of human interaction. Or if he does understand it, he's not insisting on it.

Episodes IV-VI were probably only as good as they were because Harrison Ford didn't say his lines the way they were written. He insisted on quality as he understood it, at his level, and functioned as an editor on the set. "I love you, too" becomes "I know." The down-to-earth character that Ford created held those films together.

There wasn't a Harrison Ford/Han Solo to do that for episodes I-III. That might have been because so much of those films were made in front of a blue screen, and the actors had no idea what the heck was really going on, so they weren't able to do the kind of self-editing that Ford did.

I mean, what's the point of having Samuel L. Jackson in your movie if you're not going to let him be Samuel L. Jackson? Mace Windu should have been one bad-ass Jedi. Why can't a Jedi be interesting and down-to-earth, too? Windu was boring as hell.

There's a recent Slate article about how Spielberg wanted to direct a Star Wars film, but Lucas never let him, for fear of Spielberg taking all the credit.

"The fear of loss is a path to the Dark Side."

If Lucas had delegated the stuff he wasn't good at (dialogue, directing) to someone else, and concentrated on what he was good at (the overall vision, producing), it could have been an all-time great product, instead of merely good.

I also like the paralells bewteen Anakin's slide to the Dark Side, trying to save Padme, and Luke's abandoning Yoda to save his friends in Cloud City. Both were risking evil to do good. It's just one got seduced by the evil and the other resisted.

I think you've brought up some really good points, viz. Star Wars and that quote from Amadeus.

In addition to the "I know" line, I'd also like to add the great "Han shoots first" controversy. Talk about displacing one note.

Noooooooo!

That was it. That was the pinnacle of that feeling. I had been laughing under my hand at every scene between and Padme up to that point (has anybody noticed that Anakin suddenly seems older than his cradle-robbing bride?), but when Darth Vader waved his arms feebly and called out, "Noooo!", I laughed out loud.

How is it that nobody, at any point, mentioned to George Lucas that such scenes were already the object of hilarity, years and years before he put it in his movie?

Noooooo!

One quibble...R2D2 led to much of the humanity in IV-VI. Han Solo was massively important, but I think the droid interaction between R2/C3PO & the humans really brought a light, humanistic quality that is missing from the prequels.

I think Lucas was planning to make Jar-Jar serve that "light, humanistic" function in I-III, but it obviously didn't work.